Do Tattoo Removal Creams Actually Work? A Doctor's View

Key Takeaways

• Tattoo removal creams are largely ineffective at completely removing tattoos.
• The chemicals in these creams can cause serious skin reactions, including burning, scarring, and discolouration.
• Laser removal, surgical excision, and dermabrasion are more reliable and safer options for tattoo removal when performed by a licensed professional.
• Tattoo removal can be a time-consuming and expensive process, requiring multiple sessions to achieve the desired results.

What Are Tattoo Removal Creams?

Tattoo removal creams are topical applications that claim to help erase unwanted tattoos. But the key question remains: can these creams work to remove the tattoo as effectively as professional treatments? 

About 11% of people with tattoos have tried to remove or cover tattoos. Tattoo removal creams are readily available in department stores and online retailers, promising a convenient at-home solution for removing unwanted tattoos. Despite their accessibility, these creams often fail to deliver effective results and can lead to skin irritation, burning, and scarring. 

While tattoo removal creams may seem like a convenient way to remove tattoos, the reality is that they are often not effective at completely removing the tattoo. Understanding the capabilities and limitations of tattoo removal creams is crucial for anyone considering this removal option for their unwanted tattoo.

How Do They Claim to Work?

Tattoo removal creams claim that they can eliminate tattoos by bleaching or peeling away the top layer of the skin, also known as epidermis. These creams often state that they break up the tattoo ink under the skin's surface, enabling its absorption or expulsion by the body. However, since tattoo ink is deeply embedded in the skin, it is extremely difficult for topical creams to reach and remove the tattoo effectively.

On top of this, most tattoo removal creams have not undergone extensive scientific testing or been approved by major regulatory agencies, including the UK's Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA). These creams can cause skin irritation, damage, and other adverse effects if misapplied. 

Common Ingredients in Tattoo Removal Creams

Tattoo removal creams often contain potent chemicals intended to break down tattoo ink and lighten skin. Here are some of the primary ingredients commonly found in these products:

• Trichloroacetic Acid (TCA): A strong peeling agent used in professional skin treatments, effective in exfoliating layers of skin but hazardous without proper supervision; it can cause burns and severe skin reactions.
• Glycolic Acid: An alpha hydroxy acid (AHA) that helps in exfoliating the skin and breaking down tattoo ink; often used in chemical peels for its mildness compared to TCA.
• Hydroquinone: A potent skin-lightening agent used to reduce pigmentation; its presence in creams aims to lighten the tattoo, but it carries risks of skin irritation and potential long-term health concerns.

Risks of At-Home Use:

While these ingredients may seem effective, using them at home can lead to several adverse effects. Here are some risks associated with at-home use:

• Redness: Inflammation and redness around the treated area, often a sign of irritation.
• Rashes: Allergic reactions or contact dermatitis can occur, causing rashes and discomfort.
• Burning: Chemical burns due to strong acids in the cream can cause significant pain and damage.
• Peeling: Excessive peeling can lead to raw, exposed skin, increasing the risk of infection.
• Permanent Scarring: Improper use of harsh chemicals can result in permanent scars.
• Permanent Skin Discoloration: Uneven skin tone and discoloration may occur, sometimes irreversible.

It is strongly recommended to consult licensed medical professionals for tattoo removal to ensure safety and effectiveness, avoiding the high risks associated with at-home chemical treatments.

Effectiveness of Tattoo Removal Creams

The effectiveness of tattoo removal creams has long been a topic of debate among dermatologists and skincare enthusiasts. While these over-the-counter products claim to offer a convenient and cost-effective way to remove unwanted tattoos, the scientific evidence suggests they are far less effective compared to professional tattoo removal methods.

Scientific Studies and Research

Numerous scientific studies and research projects have investigated the efficacy of tattoo removal creams. The consensus from these studies is that these creams are generally ineffective at completely removing tattoos. 

Tattoo ink is injected into the deeper layers of the skin (the dermis), and the surface-level treatments provided by creams simply cannot penetrate deep enough to actually remove the tattoo ink.

At best, tattoo removal creams may cause the tattoo to fade slightly, but they are unlikely to ever fully erase the ink. In many cases, the use of these creams can lead to distorted, discoloured versions of the original tattoo, as well as the risk of developing permanent scarring or skin damage.

Comparison with Other Tattoo Removal Methods

When compared to professional tattoo removal techniques, such as laser treatments, surgical excision, dermabrasion, and chemical peels, tattoo removal creams pale in effectiveness. These medical-grade procedures are designed to target the deeper layers of the skin where the tattoo ink resides, allowing for more complete and effective removal of the unwanted ink.

Laser tattoo removal in particular, has emerged as one of the most successful and widely used methods for tattoo removal. Treatments such as the Phantom™ Laser Tattoo Removal are able to specifically target and break down tattoo pigments, allowing the body to naturally flush them out over time. Surgical excision and dermabrasion techniques also offer reliable results, though they may be more invasive and carry a higher risk of scarring.

Pros and Cons of Using Tattoo Removal Creams

While tattoo removal creams may seem like a convenient and cost-effective solution, it's essential to weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks before considering their use. 

Benefits:

• Accessibility: Widely available in retail stores and online.
• Non-invasive: Offers a less invasive alternative to professional techniques like laser treatments or surgical excision.

Drawbacks:

• Ineffectiveness: Cannot penetrate deeply enough to reach and break up tattoo ink in the dermis.
• Unsatisfactory results: Generally less effective than professional methods, leading to potentially distorted outcomes.

Potential Side Effects:

• Skin irritation: Redness, rashes, burning, peeling.
• Serious risks: Permanent scarring, skin discoloration.
• Severe reactions: Inflammation, allergic reactions, hives, swelling, difficulty breathing, nausea, vomiting, and rare cases of anaphylaxis.

Factors to Consider Before Choosing Tattoo Removal Creams

When it comes to removing unwanted tattoos, not all techniques may work equally well for your unique situation. Several factors, such as your skin type, skin sensitivity, the size and colour of your tattoo, as well as the duration and consistency of your treatment, can significantly influence the effectiveness and safety of your chosen method.

1. Skin Type and Sensitivity

If you have sensitive skin or a history of adverse reactions, you should take care when considering the use of tattoo removal creams. These products often contain harsh chemicals like trichloroacetic acid that can cause irritation, redness, burning, and even permanent scarring or discolouration, especially for those with sensitive skin. 

Your doctor may recommend alternative options, such as laser removal or surgical excision, which are typically safer and more effective for individuals with sensitive skin.

2. Tattoo Size and Colour

The size and colour of your tattoo can also impact the success of removal treatments. Larger tattoos and those with vibrant or deep colours may prove more challenging to remove completely, even with professional methods like laser therapy. 

Tattoo removal creams are generally less effective on these types of tattoos, and you may require multiple sessions or a combination of treatments to achieve satisfactory results.

3. Duration and Consistency of Use

Consistent and prolonged use of tattoo removal creams is crucial for any potential success. However, this can be time-consuming and tedious, especially if you have a larger tattoo. 

Failing to follow the recommended application schedule or using the product inconsistently may result in little to no visible improvement, leaving you frustrated and potentially dealing with undesirable side effects.

Before you go...

As you navigate the world of tattoo removal and the challenges of over-the-counter creams, it's important to stay well-informed about all your options.

If you're curious about safe and effective ways to remove tattoos, check out our other articles for deeper insights. From the latest advancements in laser technology to expert advice on different removal methods, we’ve got you covered. 

By exploring these topics, you'll be equipped with the knowledge to make the best decisions for your skin and health. Discover the information you need to choose the right path for your tattoo removal journey.

Related Articles

• Is Laser Safe for Dark Skin? - Ask Dr Emanuel Paleco
• What Are The Most Difficult Tattoo Ink Colours to Remove?
• Can You Completely Remove A Black Tattoo?
• Laser Tattoo Removal in London (The World's Fastest & Safest)

About Institute of Medical Physics 

The Institute of Medical Physics, founded by Dr. Emanuel Paleco, is a premier medical laboratory specialising in Medical and Aesthetic Laser Science. With a flagship clinic in King’s Cross and additional locations in North London and Essex, the Institute is at the forefront of laser science innovation.

Experience advanced laser science and innovative medical treatments. Book a consultation with Dr. Emanuel Paleco and his expert team at the Institute of Medical Physics. Contact us today to schedule your appointment and start your journey towards rejuvenation.